Excellent piece over at Divester on sharing air.
If a diver is hurting for air, they might start to panic. They’ll want the first regulator that they see and know has air: the one in your mouth. It’s a good idea to stay in control of your regulator. If a diver looks like they may need air, place your hand on your regulator. It’s better for you to hand it to them than have it yanked out of your mouth. You can make sure you grab a nice breath of air and demonstrate that you’re calm while handing it over. Someone who’s been swimming without an air supply will usually feel the need to catch their breath. If you just exhaled and a panicked diver grabs your regulator, you may not be very happy while they’re gobbling up air.
I’ve only had to share air once and it was in Cozumel on a vacation. We had done a deep dive in the morning but we had a fairly aggressive profile for our second dive. The DM suggested we do a good 5 min or more safety stop before surfacing which I felt was a pretty good idea. I’m not sure why but I became a little bored on the dive and decided to cut it short. I parterned my buddy up with another pair of divers and swam back to the anchor line where I did my extended safety stop. Near the end of my stop a pair of inexerpeinced divers (they were on their 4th post-certification dive) approached me on the safety line. My instructor instincts kicked in naturally and I glanced down at their pressure gagues and noted that both divers were in the red zone. I called them both close to me and held their guages up to their eye level so they could see that they were running low. Neither of them was going to make the 5 minute recommended safety stop at their current rate of consumption so I signaled to one of them that I was going to give her my octopus. She took it as the needle on her SPG started to approach 0 and I grabbed the waiststrap on the other diver’s BCD figuring I could share air with him if needed. I wanted to prevent panic and a shoot for the surface so I attempted to keep both divers calm by not appearing to be overly concerned about the situation.
As the second diver’s SPG approached zero I noted that the DM was leading a group up the line. I gave the line a few good yanks to grab his attention and he swam up. I showed him the two SPG’s and he gave the second diver his octo. I had noted the time when the other two divers had approached me so I knew when they had had a good 5 minutes of off-gassing. When we hit the 5 minute mark I signaled to everyone that we were going to make a nice, easy ascent and we got everyone on the surface.
My first (and hopefully last) air sharing experience went rather calmly. I don’t think either diver realized in how much danger they were in. I’m quite sure the situation would have turned out very differently had they taken a hit and they couldn’t draw any air.
As an instructor, I always knew that I shouldered a special risk. You are in charge of a group of people who do not know how to dive yet. As long as you can lead them they should be fine but what if something should happen to you? I’ve always felt like being on a teaching dive was like being a solo diver. I don’t really have a buddy who I can count on to react calmly to the situation.
I’ve experimented around with carrying a pony bottle and having three air source (reg, octo, and BC octo) but in analyzing the situation I’ve come to the realization that in an emergency, as an instructor diving with inexperienced divers, the first thing they are likely to go for is the reg that’s in my mouth. That leaves me without an air source and attempting to help a diver at some level of panic. I don’t have time to waste in finding my octo so the normal placement affixed to the BC shoulder strap doesn’t seem optimal. The octo could easily become dislodged during a dive without my knowledge and then I’m wasting time sweeping behind me trying to find an air source.
The solution I like best is the DIR-inspired necklace. It keeps the octo near your mouth and it’s much more noticable when it becomes dislodged. I’ve practiced with it and can actually get the octo in my mouth without using my hands. It’s much cleaner to use my hands but it can be done simply by dipping one’s neck.
Fortunately, I haven’t had to test this configuration out in a real incident but I do make sure to communicate the location of my octo to my buddy and students when I dive. If anything, I think the unusual placement sticks out in people’s heads and I’ve gotten quite a few “That’s not a half bad idea,” from other divers.